Authors Intentions
Tue, 7 Apr 2009, 07:13 pmPaul Treasure39 posts in thread
Authors Intentions
Tue, 7 Apr 2009, 07:13 pmOkay, this is a serious question for me...
A number of different posts recently have gotten quite seriously into Dramatic Theory, and one thing that keeps popping up is "The Author's Intention".
Now, when I was younger I had Roland Barthes' theory of "The Death of the Author" drummed into me.
To try and put it simply - The meaning of any work of art or literature is the meaning that the reader/watcher gets from it, and any interpretation is valid as long as the text bears it out, and what the author originally intended is largely irrelevant...
(My apologies if I put it clumsily, it WAS YEARS ago)
But this was a literary/philosophical theory, not a purely dramatic one.
My question is:
Has Roland Barthes been thrown out and someone forgot to forward me the memo?
or,
As his theory is a general literary theory not a specific dramatic one, has it just not filtered through to the performing arts?
Can't say I'm losing sleep over it or anything, but it has piqued my interest :-)
Interesting you should
Sun, 19 Apr 2009, 04:41 pmInteresting you should mention translation. One of my plays has been translated into Greek and another (the abovementioned political play) into Hindi.
I was benused by the first as it was a very English comedy and I am still wondering how some of the jokes worked in Greek, obviously they were transliterated (is that a word?) as well as translated. I speak no Greek at all.
The Hindi translation I'm sure worked.
Someone is currently working on translating one of my plays for a South African Afrikaans company although the production may never happen.
I did not mean to belittle you. I was not aware of your other endeavours and looked upon you as an actor (a breed for whom I have much respect developed while watching them struggle with my words).
I may have appeared to be more difficult than I actually am about my words. I suspect I reacted by moving to a stronger position than I really feel. That doesn't mean that I will react quite strongly if I feel that my work is being butchered.
I do see your point about a Directors viewpoint and obviously if directing my own work I stick to my original intent but I admit that directing others work I do look for ways to make it more valid in the situation it is being presented in. I still feel that some directors can and do take this too far in quite a cavalier fashion.
Is that all there is? Well if that's all there is my friend, then let's keep dancing.
www.tonymoore.id.au
- ···
- ···
- ···