Bumpy Angels
Sun, 2 July 2000, 12:07 pmWalter Plinge27 posts in thread
Bumpy Angels
Sun, 2 July 2000, 12:07 pmHello everyone! Well, lets see if we can cause some more controversy!(not that that's what i set out to do)
Bumpy Angels is a strange mish-mash of song, personal revelation (and even) game show. Unfortunately I was put off from the beginning with the intolerably long procession of "brides" which had no relevance to any later scenes - merely some sort of masque to get us in the mood (and failing). Firstly the backstage crew were laughable - taking ages just to move a cupboard and later making mistakes (coming in and off in half light) and then very audiblely chastising/discussing backstage - to was so bad the audience couldn't help but giggle. Mind you, we were already in a bemused state after being subjected to various snatches of song which are incredibly cheesy and I think lent nothing to the play - they could all be cut and play would lose nothing (might even gain a bit of dramatic credibility). By the interval I was pleased with the dramatic tension set up between characters and the audience was certainly emotionally involved - some of us rather uncomfortably so! But then it just kept coming! Coral and Felicity-Elizabeth's monologues were quite touching and well performed - but then everybody had to get in on the act, confessing every dark secret and troubled soul. Destroying most of the poignancy and subtlety of the play we were sledgehammered with emotion until the unsatisfying conclusion. High praise must goto the Mother Superior, who showed excellent charactisation and crystal clear vocal technique. Singing numbers were a little ragged and out of time and of course not all of us can be singers (Angela and Amy's song certainly made us long for a chorus number) but Your CHeatin' Heart was an absolute delight. All in all an emotion packed and interesting show, which cheapens itself through lack of any subtlety and its silly songs.
Bumpy Angels is a strange mish-mash of song, personal revelation (and even) game show. Unfortunately I was put off from the beginning with the intolerably long procession of "brides" which had no relevance to any later scenes - merely some sort of masque to get us in the mood (and failing). Firstly the backstage crew were laughable - taking ages just to move a cupboard and later making mistakes (coming in and off in half light) and then very audiblely chastising/discussing backstage - to was so bad the audience couldn't help but giggle. Mind you, we were already in a bemused state after being subjected to various snatches of song which are incredibly cheesy and I think lent nothing to the play - they could all be cut and play would lose nothing (might even gain a bit of dramatic credibility). By the interval I was pleased with the dramatic tension set up between characters and the audience was certainly emotionally involved - some of us rather uncomfortably so! But then it just kept coming! Coral and Felicity-Elizabeth's monologues were quite touching and well performed - but then everybody had to get in on the act, confessing every dark secret and troubled soul. Destroying most of the poignancy and subtlety of the play we were sledgehammered with emotion until the unsatisfying conclusion. High praise must goto the Mother Superior, who showed excellent charactisation and crystal clear vocal technique. Singing numbers were a little ragged and out of time and of course not all of us can be singers (Angela and Amy's song certainly made us long for a chorus number) but Your CHeatin' Heart was an absolute delight. All in all an emotion packed and interesting show, which cheapens itself through lack of any subtlety and its silly songs.
RE: Bumpy Angels
Sun, 2 July 2000, 04:34 pmWalter Plinge
It seems to me from the way you write your "reviews" Secret Squirrel that you have no idea about the real reasons we all do Community Theatre. It is an arena for us all to show off our talents, improve what we know, have a go at something new and above all meet new people and have a bit of FUN. This is not to say we shouldn't strive for as good as we can be in our performances, direction etc, but please give people a break, we all still have an everyday life too. If we are getting paid $700 a week and rehearsing 7 hours a day, five days a week, then yes we would expect something amazing.
You say in your opening line "let's see if we can cause some controversy again (though it's not what you set out to do) - WRONG! - if you hadn't that thought in mind then you wouldn't have opened with it. I mean these pages should be a forum for suggestion, congratulation, support, encouragement, informed criticism and yes if something really deserves it -praise.
I'm not saying that you shouldn't voice your thoughts on a show, but there is a way of doing it without it or yourself sounding so 'Holier than thou'. I mean calling the backstage crew 'laughable'. Come on. We don't know what happened that night. There actually could have been a very good reason for why things went wrong for them that evening.
This next piece of advice is a little old hat and cliched but it is true. A review is supposed to be constructive...not destructive. And by the way I agree with a lot of the other people on this web page. If you are going to be negative about something at least have the decency and maturity to do it openly.
(And if you are wondering, this is from someone who is not even remotely connected with 'Bumpy Angels')
You say in your opening line "let's see if we can cause some controversy again (though it's not what you set out to do) - WRONG! - if you hadn't that thought in mind then you wouldn't have opened with it. I mean these pages should be a forum for suggestion, congratulation, support, encouragement, informed criticism and yes if something really deserves it -praise.
I'm not saying that you shouldn't voice your thoughts on a show, but there is a way of doing it without it or yourself sounding so 'Holier than thou'. I mean calling the backstage crew 'laughable'. Come on. We don't know what happened that night. There actually could have been a very good reason for why things went wrong for them that evening.
This next piece of advice is a little old hat and cliched but it is true. A review is supposed to be constructive...not destructive. And by the way I agree with a lot of the other people on this web page. If you are going to be negative about something at least have the decency and maturity to do it openly.
(And if you are wondering, this is from someone who is not even remotely connected with 'Bumpy Angels')
- ···
- ···
- ···
- ···
- ···
- ···
- ···
- ···
- ···
- ···
- ···
- ···
- ···