Theatre Australia

your portal for australian theatre

Rent - WA Regal Theatre

Mon, 12 Nov 2007, 11:07 pm
Asta57 posts in thread
Okay so it was bound to happen a review of RENT. Firstly I know that this post is going to cause contraversy and I'm prepared for the barrage of tweenies who will defend their pop idols to the end. So I will say it now... this is only my opinion and I am entitled to it. I also think that when it comes to reviewing I try to be as fair and informative as possible without getting too personal as I know how hard it is to put on a show like this. So here goes. I went and saw the Sunday night (November 11th) performance of RENT. I was very surprised by the small audience considering how much advertising this show has had. Overall I had an enjoyable experience of Rent. It wasn't fantastic and it wasn't crap but it was a nice way to spend a Sunday afternoon. What I didn't like: The first half seemed very slow and very unenlivaning (I know I spelt that wrong). The opening song of Rent was painful to watch. That song is about tension and the music moves at such a pace that something exciting should be going on. But all the characters did was look either at each other or out into the audience and sing their lines. It was boring. I hated the end. Maureen and Joanne rolled up thier coats in such a way that when Mimi lied down to almost die she looked incredibly uncomfortable and it looked terrible. Roger should have had more connection with her at this point but instead he seemed very detatched and apart from her. The girl is dying the least you could do is touch her. There were a lot of instances where the characters sang out into the audience and I mean a lot of instances. Sometimes it worked but a lot of the time it just made me feel very uncomfortable and made the actors look like they had forgotten what they were suppossed to do next. Out tonight was boring. Jaya needed to let go more and be much more sexual. She seemed confined in that small spaced and clumsy climbing on the railings. The voice was fantastic she just needed the moves to match. Ruth was too young to play the mother and her timing was very off in this performance. Which is disspointing cause I know how talented she is. What I loved: Shane Janek. All I can say is wait for act II. He seemed really nervous at the beginning (and almost out of breath in today for you tomorrow for me) but he hit everything perfect in the second act. Joanne! What an amazing voice. She was fantastic. Every time she sang I was amazed but she really shon in Take me or Leave me especially when competing with the star power of Nikki. She was a brilliant actress and singer and her short dance in Tango maureen left Anthony to shame. He couldn't keep up. The guy who played Collin was fantastic. During the reprise of I'll cover you I was nearly in tears. His voice was so full of emotion and he was so beautiful to listen to and watch. an amazing talent. The staging was excellent and allowed the cast to create very distinct areas for the story to unfold. I also liked the idea of having the band on stage. It was very eariee to see the drug dealer guy slink out from under the scaffolding too. The Christmas bell guy stole the show every time he came on stage. Just goes to show you don't need a big part to be a star. He was so funny and had great timing. Good singer too. The voices. The entire cast and I mean entire cast was fantastic vocally. Couldn't fault a single one of them. The Idols: Nikki. I really think that despite a fantastic voice and a really sound performance, she was not right for the part of Maureen. She looked too young and like she was trying too hard to be comfortable with being a bitch and a slut. She also didn't match up with Joanne very well who I loved. But what a voice. Anthony. What a beautiful voice. He was gorgeous to listen to but dreadful to watch. He didn't do anything. It was like watching Ken act. He was very very boring. Shane. I've said enough. Actually I've said enough all together. I could go on for hours. There was so much that I enjoyed about this show and so much I hated. All in all if you have the cash it is worth a look, but I wouldn't make a special trip for it. Love for now Kate. Looking forward to the backlash.

I saw Rent on Friday the

Tue, 13 Nov 2007, 10:13 am
Walter Plinge
I saw Rent on Friday the 9th and I have to agree with Kate in the original post. I hadn't seen Rent staged before and so was looking forward to it and I was quite disappointed. For the most part I was just totally bored; I found it hard understand what was going on and there didn't seem to be a lot of flow; it was all disjointed and more like a concert version. I guess the biggest thing for me is that I didn't feel the characters; it was just people singing. I agree that the death scene at the end was just terrible; I almost laughed, it seemed like something out of a daytime soap opera...very melodramatic. And yes, it must have been terrible on Broadway too if this is how they did it there. Technically-wise, I thought the lighting was great, very sharp and great operation on the night that I saw it, so well done to the operator/s. The sound was all over the place, and it might just have been the mike quality, but the vocals sounded very tinny and made it extremely hard to understand what was being said in a lot of parts especially since I didn't know the lyrics. The band was really good; a little loud at the beginning but the levels were soon under control and it was great to hear some fabulous musicians playing some great songs. Performers; As mentioned in a previous post, Shai was absolutely outstanding...the reprise of I'll Cover You was the only time in the show that I was completely lost in what was happening on stage. What a magnificent voice this man has and not a fault to be heard. Just listening to this one song almost made it worth the price of my ticket. I also loved Joannes voice; very strong and very clear...another standout for me. I quite liked Nikki Webster in her solo song, the rest of the performance didnt do much for me, but I thought she did well on her own. I don't like Anthony Calleas nasal voice particularly and his acting was shocking. Tim Campbell was better; I liked his edgy rock sound but his vocal performance wasn't consistent. I do however, think his acting was better than the other two. I was very impressed with Shane Janek; he seemed very in control of his entire performance and I enjoyed his character. I guess this is the great debate that has gone on in the lead up and will probably never stop, but James, I don't care if it is Anthony's first or second musical, for the money that I paid to see this show, I expect all of the performers to be fantastic.... and in character at least. I know that a lot of work went into this show and I absolutely appreciate that, but a great singer does not automatically make a great musical theatre performer.This is all just my opinion, and if you loved this show, that is great because it makes the hard work worthwhile to stage a show like this. Unfortunately I thought it was below the overall standard that I expected. But thank you to all involved for the effort that has gone into this, and best of luck to everyone for the rest of the run.

Thread (57 posts)

← Back to Theatre Reviews