Theatre Australia

your portal for australian theatre

Them good ol' moderation blues...

Tue, 5 Apr 2011, 02:07 pm
Bass Guy26 posts in thread
This is an old chestnut of mine, but... I've noticed in the reviews section a couple of instances where unfawning comments have been moderated down- simply because they didn't follow the rapturous praise of other postings on the same thread. This happened with "Zastrozzi" a week or two ago, and has just happened on Gordon's "Company" review thread today. Neither of these posts could be construed as trolling, slanderous or even mean-spritied; it's just they had the nerve NOT to say "This is the best (fill in the blank) I've ever seen...". Some of the critisisms offered were pointed, certainly- but well reasoned, and certainly nothing that amounted to hate-mail. In the case of the Zastrozzi one, it DISAPPEARED COMPLETELY from the site. I went back to read it again and it had simply vanished, and I've been unable to locate it again. And considering one of the chief admin folk here was in that particular show, one is tempted to smell a rat or two.... And this is one of the problems I have with moderation (as I've bleated about from the get-go); sure you can "moderate things up", but should you have to? If someone is silly enough to post something hateful (and I'm as guilty of that as anyone on this site) leave it up and let people respond to it. Don't hide it because it disagrees with the general tenor of the conversation. I like reasoned debate- if I want irrational stupidity, I'll read (or post on) facebook. I would have thought this site could withstand more open discussion. What are everyone else's thoughts? Assuming this hasn't been moderated out of public view.... Eliot McCann

yay

Tue, 19 Apr 2011, 01:33 pm
I only come back occasionally and good to see something of substance again. Simple- either can moderation (read censorship) completely, or have as someone suggested above a youtube-like like/dislike button. Then people can vote, but the post doesn't just disappear. Personally CBF moderating up. Of course, obvious trolling or material that simply would not be allowed in common society should be removed. The probs I understand with this are that you then end up with the site being vulnerable to litigation if it in any ways is moderated for content. (e.g. read the blackbox thread from years back...oh wait, you can't!) and I too believe only a registered person should be allowed to post. Under their real name. In full public glory. We are after all presumably all adults here and of at least basic intelligence. If you disagree with someone, WHY?! Spend 30 seconds thinking what about this post irks you and use logic and reason to refute the comment, if you can. If you can't, it's possible you are wrong and maybe the inspiration to consider your position honestly will make you a better artist, or even person! Anyone who can't handle this needs to get out of this industry right away, you are simply too soft. Leave it to those with the guts to challenge themselves honestly (and take even the unfair bashes) to make the art. Or don't come here and read the reviews... I have always posted under my real name, and have posted both great and bad reviews of shows in the past. I believe not being anonymous encouraged me to consider my criticisms carefully and to provide moderated and intelligent feedback to those in the shows I reviewed. It has also made me a target on multiple occasions, both on this site and in the real world, and I am fairly certain has caused me to lose out on work as well. I no longer am willing to review for this reason. I need work, and it simply doesn't work in a town the size of Perth to be brutally honest about the fact that there are a lot of sacred cows in town, and maybe it isn't all as spectacular as we think... some very good stuff yes, but not a lot of truly excellent, and a lot of truly not good. What is wrong with admitting this?! However, I will continue to have some balls and post in the open where my community can judge my thoughts and comments in their unedited glory. Whatever the punishment. Nev It's the simple things stupid...

Thread (26 posts)

← Back to Green Room Gossip