Theatre Australia

your portal for australian theatre

GRADS - "How to lose friends and offend some people" Ron Banks

Tue, 29 June 2010, 12:13 pm
millie8112 posts in thread
REVIEW IN TODAYS WEST AUSTRALIAN - RON BANKS WITH FRIENDS LIKE THESE - DOLPHIN THEATRE Based on what I saw of the opening night, GRADS has made an error of judgment in allowing Edgar Metcalfe's previously unproduced play to go ahead. No doubt it was motivated by a desire to say farewell to Metcalfe, who retires home to England after the season, in the nicest possible way. To acknowledge this contribution to theatre over 50 years by allowing him to direct the only play of the six he has written that had not seen the light of day. Big mistake. The first half is embarrassing, simply unfunny and tasteless in the extreme. I confess to having fled at interval, so I cannot tell you the ending. One sensible couple fled during the scene change in act one. My main objection is the way the play makes fun of a character who is given a very bad stutter. The poor actor given the stutter's lines (I won't name him because he probably has a day job) must engage in the most egregious vocal contortions to get his words out, and it is embarrassing and uncomfortable to watch. And it is definitely not funny. To caricature such an afflication is such an offensive move that I'm surprised that Metcalfe surrended to the temptation in his supposed comedy of manners about a group of people gathered for a party to celebrate the marriage of the stutterer to a young woman whi is pregnant to another man. Surely someone in GRADS was offended by the tasteless portrayal and wanted to speak up about it's inclusion. But with Metcalfe as writer and director - and also a board member of the company - this might have been stifled by fear of offending the playwright. Well it offended me and I'm speaking up about it. There is a temptation to let these types of productions slide under the radar because they are put on by enthusiastic amateur thespians.But they do charge money for people to see them and people should be warned. Apart from the problem of the stutter, the first half lacks wit or cleverness ............................. _____________________________________________________________________________________________ We saw that show on Saturday and overall enjoyed it. According to their website Edgar is not a part of the GRADS committee. Wondering if Mr Banks has gone for a final farewell attack hoping to cause an effect? Edgar has achieved many wonderful things in theatre and she be recognised as such - it will be a loss for Perth when he heads home to Blackpool Mx

Pride & Prejudice

Thu, 1 July 2010, 11:16 pm

I would dearly love to write a few words about the review in Tuesday's West, however, as I'm in the cast, I think it would be circumspect to wait until the season has finished, so I shall, in the meantime, a couple of things:

I am aware the staff at the West debated long and hard as to whether to run Ron's review, eventually deciding to do so, as they had already printed the two page article on Edgar - a question of balance and as a freelance photo-journalist, I have the utmost respect for that decision.

Secondly, two people did indeed leave at interval on the Saturday night - we (the cast) didn't see them, however the Stage Manager made us immediately aware, although I'm not sure what the motivational point was in telling us at that time.

It’s interesting to see that the comments centred around my age and body shape are being voted down – perhaps people feel I might be offended? I’m not remotely – I am who I am and I really like the bloke (faults and all!). But what is worse, Ron Banks outrage at what he saw as cruel ridicule of a speech impediment, or the comment from the young lady assuming / taking / of the name Charlotte Dyer, who exhibits her prejudice, ridiculing the concept of a pretty young girl and an old fat bloke?

I suspect she meant no malice, she’s just too young and inexperienced in life to understand the subtext of what she was writing / saying, which is why it is so often absurd to have young people playing mature roles, although they may have the craft, they don’t have the experience of life to flesh-out a mature role.

I really believe all of us can learn from criticism and not let pride get in the way, but prejudice defines us and gets in the way.

All Good Things

Greg Ross

Minister for Good Times

Thread (12 posts)

← Back to Theatre Reviews