The Taming of the Shrew
Sat, 8 Mar 2003, 02:17 amWalter Plinge8 posts in thread
The Taming of the Shrew
Sat, 8 Mar 2003, 02:17 amWHAT: The Taming of the Shrew
WHEN: Friday, March 7 (2003)
WHERE: GRADS, New Fortune Theatre, University of WA
I was challenged to write a review that wasn't ten pages long and utterly boring. Okay, this won't be ten pages long.
The Graduate Dramatic Society has extended its reputation for presenting quality Shakespearean productions. This was one of the most cleverly and lovingly directed productions I've seen in a long time. Direction can sometimes be overshadowed by performances. The general public will usually walk out saying, "Wasn't Joe Bloggs good (or bad)," but rarely say, "Wasn't it well directed." The director can often be overlooked, unless a show is really good or really bad. This was really good.
Director Stephen Lee is new to Perth, but has years of experience behind him in the UK. Honestly, we're talking decades. The man must be positively ancient. We know that Will's plays have little, if any, stage directions, making them extremely susceptible to interpretation. (Is that one of the reasons they've survived for so long? Thoughts?) Stephen has thought out and choreographed every line. It's very funny and it really is a joy to watch.
Unfortunately, it's not such a joy to listen to. I'm not trying to be nasty, but there were some real problems with acoustics. It wasn't an overall problem - some of the cast could be understood perfectly, but a bit too much of the dialogue was lost in the reverb and echo. Sometimes I had no idea what the hell was going on.
Five hundred years ago, were people smarter or dumber? Did Shakespeare pad out his flimsy plots with superfluous subplots so as to keep the masses entertained, or did they see more in it than us? Why did Lucentio and Tranio swap identities? Why did Tranio (pretending to be Lucentio) woo Bianca for Lucentio? Why didn't Lucentio just do it himself? Why did Lucentio (pretending to be Tranio) start goosestepping all over the stage and using a Colonel Klink accent? Why did Tranio sometimes sound like Don Corleone and sometimes like Tony Soprano? These (and many other small queries) may have been explained, but no one I spoke to heard them
Regardless of the occasionally meandering script, it was a strong cast led by David Meadows and Maggie McPhee, complemented by many GRADS regulars. The servants very nearly stole the entire show, in particular Leah Maher and Dario Dalla Costa, but don't tell them or it'll go to their heads.
The costumes were stunning - absolutely gorgeous for the most part. The guys' suits were stylish and smart, while the ladies were particularly feminine (there are enough bloody men in the world - I can't fathom why the current trend is for women to increasingly dress like them). I have to make special mention of Fiona Mondello's tailor's outfit - how can I not commend the stunning green frock and black seamed stockings? Congratulations to Wardrobe Manager, Robina Maitland-Smith.
I hope I haven't sounded too critical. If they can do something about the sound it will be as close to perfect as a Shakespeare can get. I must admit, the sound was much better in Act 2, so maybe mention was made, or else the audience was getting used to it. It is difficult to tell when you're so close and accustomed to the lines, which is why as an outsider, I hope I'm being helpful in saying, "Do something about it." (Less shouting, maybe?)
Anyway, you have to go and see it. It's GRADS' annual Shakespeare for goodness' sake. You KNOW it's going to be good. And what's more, it's energetic, fresh and very, very funny. It's got a hard-working, enthusiastic and young cast (plus Collin O'Brien - that's what you get for not coming out the front to say G'Day). Stephen Lee has brought an all new energy to what many people casually dismiss (Bah, Shakespeare!), and I'm sure he's going to be in demand in the future.
Thanks again,
JB
WHEN: Friday, March 7 (2003)
WHERE: GRADS, New Fortune Theatre, University of WA
I was challenged to write a review that wasn't ten pages long and utterly boring. Okay, this won't be ten pages long.
The Graduate Dramatic Society has extended its reputation for presenting quality Shakespearean productions. This was one of the most cleverly and lovingly directed productions I've seen in a long time. Direction can sometimes be overshadowed by performances. The general public will usually walk out saying, "Wasn't Joe Bloggs good (or bad)," but rarely say, "Wasn't it well directed." The director can often be overlooked, unless a show is really good or really bad. This was really good.
Director Stephen Lee is new to Perth, but has years of experience behind him in the UK. Honestly, we're talking decades. The man must be positively ancient. We know that Will's plays have little, if any, stage directions, making them extremely susceptible to interpretation. (Is that one of the reasons they've survived for so long? Thoughts?) Stephen has thought out and choreographed every line. It's very funny and it really is a joy to watch.
Unfortunately, it's not such a joy to listen to. I'm not trying to be nasty, but there were some real problems with acoustics. It wasn't an overall problem - some of the cast could be understood perfectly, but a bit too much of the dialogue was lost in the reverb and echo. Sometimes I had no idea what the hell was going on.
Five hundred years ago, were people smarter or dumber? Did Shakespeare pad out his flimsy plots with superfluous subplots so as to keep the masses entertained, or did they see more in it than us? Why did Lucentio and Tranio swap identities? Why did Tranio (pretending to be Lucentio) woo Bianca for Lucentio? Why didn't Lucentio just do it himself? Why did Lucentio (pretending to be Tranio) start goosestepping all over the stage and using a Colonel Klink accent? Why did Tranio sometimes sound like Don Corleone and sometimes like Tony Soprano? These (and many other small queries) may have been explained, but no one I spoke to heard them
Regardless of the occasionally meandering script, it was a strong cast led by David Meadows and Maggie McPhee, complemented by many GRADS regulars. The servants very nearly stole the entire show, in particular Leah Maher and Dario Dalla Costa, but don't tell them or it'll go to their heads.
The costumes were stunning - absolutely gorgeous for the most part. The guys' suits were stylish and smart, while the ladies were particularly feminine (there are enough bloody men in the world - I can't fathom why the current trend is for women to increasingly dress like them). I have to make special mention of Fiona Mondello's tailor's outfit - how can I not commend the stunning green frock and black seamed stockings? Congratulations to Wardrobe Manager, Robina Maitland-Smith.
I hope I haven't sounded too critical. If they can do something about the sound it will be as close to perfect as a Shakespeare can get. I must admit, the sound was much better in Act 2, so maybe mention was made, or else the audience was getting used to it. It is difficult to tell when you're so close and accustomed to the lines, which is why as an outsider, I hope I'm being helpful in saying, "Do something about it." (Less shouting, maybe?)
Anyway, you have to go and see it. It's GRADS' annual Shakespeare for goodness' sake. You KNOW it's going to be good. And what's more, it's energetic, fresh and very, very funny. It's got a hard-working, enthusiastic and young cast (plus Collin O'Brien - that's what you get for not coming out the front to say G'Day). Stephen Lee has brought an all new energy to what many people casually dismiss (Bah, Shakespeare!), and I'm sure he's going to be in demand in the future.
Thanks again,
JB
Re: The Taming of the Shrew
Sun, 9 Mar 2003, 03:02 pmWalter Plinge
Sitting through "bad" Shakespeare is about as much fun as stapling one's bottom lip to one's own left buttock, however, watching the Bard done CORRECTLY is one of life's greatest joys! And this production of Shrew is about as good as you'll ever see. It is sublime!!!!!
I've seen this done professionally a few times now, I'm sure most of us have. In my humble opinion, it's always struck me as a particularly misogynistic piece of tripe. BUT, for the first time ever, I watched it and DIDn't grind my teeth/crack the shits/burn my bra. Ah interpretation! Where would we be without it??
This play has been exquisitely directed. Steve has approached the text from a fresh angle and it works beautifully. And it's FUNNY,y'all! Laugh out loud, PISS funny! If comedy is difficult to do, then surely the trickiest of comedy styles to pull off is slapstick. This cast's comic timing and delivery was impecable! A bloke being clocked in the nuts/a bloke running into a wall NEVER stops being funny. Never! On this note I'd like to especially congradulate Leah Maher, Mark Blades, Giovanni Bartuccio, shirley welch and Dario Della Costa for their hiLARious performances!! I've seen Mark and Leah do "serious" stuff before now and they are both terrific actors. Their flair for comedy however is more than a little awesome! Y'all CRACKed me up! (Mark, that really bad wig you wear does upstage you a bit, BTW...)
I must jump on the Worst Acoustics EVER! bandwagon. Sorry, the New Fortune may well be the closest thing Perth has to a bona fide Shakers theatre, but the sound is still rubbish. Also, were the "accents" REALLY necessary?? Giovanni's didn't seem to know where his was and the German accent made the lovely Mr Petani rather difficult to understand.
Finally, maybe it's just me, but have any of you ever longed for a role, and not gotten it and then gone and seen the production hoping, nay PRAYing that the person who DID get would be really crap?? Well, Ms Maggie McPhee (ooh, I'll be sore tomorrow...) you were brilliant love! I wanted to dislike your performance, hell I tried! There are only so many sour grapes a precious and fragile beast like myself can stomah though! And credit where credit is due, you nailed Kate! This was the first time I ever felt for Kate or even liked her. And it's the first time I've seen her fall in love with Petruccio! It was a powerful, thoughtful and most importantly truthful portayal. Thank you!
A stellar cast with expert direction! Mr Lee has been sent to us as a gift by the benevolent ghost of Larry Olivier, I'm sure of it! Audition for all his plays, attend his courses, go watch him perform! He's just what we've always needed here!
J x
I've seen this done professionally a few times now, I'm sure most of us have. In my humble opinion, it's always struck me as a particularly misogynistic piece of tripe. BUT, for the first time ever, I watched it and DIDn't grind my teeth/crack the shits/burn my bra. Ah interpretation! Where would we be without it??
This play has been exquisitely directed. Steve has approached the text from a fresh angle and it works beautifully. And it's FUNNY,y'all! Laugh out loud, PISS funny! If comedy is difficult to do, then surely the trickiest of comedy styles to pull off is slapstick. This cast's comic timing and delivery was impecable! A bloke being clocked in the nuts/a bloke running into a wall NEVER stops being funny. Never! On this note I'd like to especially congradulate Leah Maher, Mark Blades, Giovanni Bartuccio, shirley welch and Dario Della Costa for their hiLARious performances!! I've seen Mark and Leah do "serious" stuff before now and they are both terrific actors. Their flair for comedy however is more than a little awesome! Y'all CRACKed me up! (Mark, that really bad wig you wear does upstage you a bit, BTW...)
I must jump on the Worst Acoustics EVER! bandwagon. Sorry, the New Fortune may well be the closest thing Perth has to a bona fide Shakers theatre, but the sound is still rubbish. Also, were the "accents" REALLY necessary?? Giovanni's didn't seem to know where his was and the German accent made the lovely Mr Petani rather difficult to understand.
Finally, maybe it's just me, but have any of you ever longed for a role, and not gotten it and then gone and seen the production hoping, nay PRAYing that the person who DID get would be really crap?? Well, Ms Maggie McPhee (ooh, I'll be sore tomorrow...) you were brilliant love! I wanted to dislike your performance, hell I tried! There are only so many sour grapes a precious and fragile beast like myself can stomah though! And credit where credit is due, you nailed Kate! This was the first time I ever felt for Kate or even liked her. And it's the first time I've seen her fall in love with Petruccio! It was a powerful, thoughtful and most importantly truthful portayal. Thank you!
A stellar cast with expert direction! Mr Lee has been sent to us as a gift by the benevolent ghost of Larry Olivier, I'm sure of it! Audition for all his plays, attend his courses, go watch him perform! He's just what we've always needed here!
J x