Theatre Australia

your portal for australian theatre

Shrew a night to be missed (rpt)

Fri, 29 Jan 1999, 11:08 am
Grant Malcolm10 posts in thread
I wish i had.Thirty thousand people are likely to see this show. I'm curious to hear responses from others that have been to see the sensation that is Shakespeare in the Park.I saw the Dream two years ago and was very impressed - not as a Shakespeare afficinado by their interpretation - just at the sheer entertainment value and energy of the performance.This year's production of The Taming of the Shrew is one of the least funny things i've seen in a long time.We arrived very early for a picnic tea and picked a spot within 3m of the stage, but had difficulty hearing a lot of the dialogue. Not that this mattered a great deal. Everything was broadcast in semaphore. Maybe it was just the night i was there and there were a lot of three year olds in the audience, but the actors found it necessary to "Act Out" every line for the benefit of the kindergarten kiddies.The extraordinary wooing of Kate by Petruchio on their first meeting was unbearably slow! It proceeded largely in excruciating silence, with the only audience response a predictable titter on "what with my tongue in your tail?" Was it really necessary for the actors to mime it?By contrast, one of Biondello's later lines "as much as an apple doth an oyster", was played for itself and received at least as good a response through well phrased and timed delivery.Brick bats to a director with little understanding of comedy or Shakespeare - bring back Glenn Elston! There was some extraordinary talent on the stage, but i nearly wept to see it reduced to dashing about frantically in search of snicker from the audience. Dumbing down invariably reflects on the "do-er" rather than their audience.Bouquets to Michael (always audible) Loney, Luke Hewitt and Igor Sas who realised some of the best laughs in the show were to come from trusting the quality of the play. Bouquets also to the team involved in the opening musical number - it was a delight!Here's my challenge:See the Shrew - if you haven't already - and then see As You Like It in the New Fortune Theatre at UWA. One is professional with some of the best talent in town, the other amateur, but i'm willing to bet the latter will enchant you and entertain you twice as much for half the price.As You Like It plays Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday until 6th February.CheersGrant

Thread (10 posts)

Grant MalcolmFri, 29 Jan 1999, 11:08 am
I wish i had.Thirty thousand people are likely to see this show. I'm curious to hear responses from others that have been to see the sensation that is Shakespeare in the Park.I saw the Dream two years ago and was very impressed - not as a Shakespeare afficinado by their interpretation - just at the sheer entertainment value and energy of the performance.This year's production of The Taming of the Shrew is one of the least funny things i've seen in a long time.We arrived very early for a picnic tea and picked a spot within 3m of the stage, but had difficulty hearing a lot of the dialogue. Not that this mattered a great deal. Everything was broadcast in semaphore. Maybe it was just the night i was there and there were a lot of three year olds in the audience, but the actors found it necessary to "Act Out" every line for the benefit of the kindergarten kiddies.The extraordinary wooing of Kate by Petruchio on their first meeting was unbearably slow! It proceeded largely in excruciating silence, with the only audience response a predictable titter on "what with my tongue in your tail?" Was it really necessary for the actors to mime it?By contrast, one of Biondello's later lines "as much as an apple doth an oyster", was played for itself and received at least as good a response through well phrased and timed delivery.Brick bats to a director with little understanding of comedy or Shakespeare - bring back Glenn Elston! There was some extraordinary talent on the stage, but i nearly wept to see it reduced to dashing about frantically in search of snicker from the audience. Dumbing down invariably reflects on the "do-er" rather than their audience.Bouquets to Michael (always audible) Loney, Luke Hewitt and Igor Sas who realised some of the best laughs in the show were to come from trusting the quality of the play. Bouquets also to the team involved in the opening musical number - it was a delight!Here's my challenge:See the Shrew - if you haven't already - and then see As You Like It in the New Fortune Theatre at UWA. One is professional with some of the best talent in town, the other amateur, but i'm willing to bet the latter will enchant you and entertain you twice as much for half the price.As You Like It plays Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday until 6th February.CheersGrant
Walter PlingeMon, 8 Feb 1999, 08:31 am

Re: Shrew a night to be missed (rpt)

I do not confess to being an experienced theatre critic, but as with all people, i know what i like...and i loved Taming of the Shrew.I was there on Saturday, the last night with my Social Club from work.I have not seen a live performance of the Shrew before, so i am unable to compare it to another performance, but as far as entertainment and a great evening goes, it was spot on!!For the non theatre lover it offered plenty to keep their interest through out the evening, this was only the second play one of my workmates had ever seen(the 1st being Lipstick Dreams at Acorn), and he thoughougly enjoyed it.Perhaps as far as offering a great interpretation of The Shrew , i do not know.I know i loved it,and the actors appeared to enjoy being up there, so much so i had to keep pulling back so as not to jump on stage too!!!Looks like a fun and challenging play to be in.....one day......hope this offered u an unqualified critics impression of the evening Grant,Sue>
Grant MalcolmMon, 8 Feb 1999, 03:11 pm

Re: Shrew a night to be missed (rpt)

Hi SueIsn't it fascinating how widely people's impressions can differ?I must admit that i was so bound up in my own disappointment (and that of the friends that we attended with) that i uncharitably forgot to mention that much of the audience seemed to enjoy the show.I don't know what "qualifies" anyone to be a theatre critic. There should be room for everyone to hold an opinion of their own regardless of their qualifications or experience.CheersGrant
Walter PlingeTue, 9 Feb 1999, 11:26 am

Re: Shrew a night to be missed (rpt)

It is the differences in peoples opinions that enriches life i think.And i guess everyone is a qualified critic in theri own right.These little debates on line are very interesting, it is always good to see others opinions.Maybe i was bias watching Taming of The Shrew, as one of the actors in the introduction Serenaded me...swoon..sigh...Sue> Hi Sue> Isn't it fascinating how widely people's impressions can differ?>> I must admit that i was so bound up in my own disappointment> (and that of the friends that we attended with) that i uncharitably> forgot to mention that much of the audience seemed to enjoy the show.>> I don't know what "qualifies" anyone to be a theatre> critic. There should be room for everyone to hold an opinion of their> own regardless of their qualifications or experience.> Cheers> Grant>
Walter PlingeTue, 9 Feb 1999, 01:04 pm

Re: Shrew a night to be missed (rpt)

So now the truth surfacesit was not just your Renouned theatrical opinion, it was emotional....However, I am rather envious,I would lurve to able to perfom in any Shakespearean play....one day....Sue> Hi Sue> i know my bias was showing. i performed in a production of the> Shrew with Michael Loney in '86 - featured John Bell (of Bell Shakespeare> fame) and Anna Volska in the leads *swoon*> i've also seen three really great productions since then> this one was the first lousy one i've seen, so it was disappointing>> Cheers> Grant
NormaTue, 9 Feb 1999, 01:49 pm

Re: Shrew a night to be missed (rpt)

Grant's experience with 'Shrew' reminds me of a recent experience of my own at another production. In this case I walked out at half time I hated it so but many others have raved about the show, so there.............( I gather I missed the best half)> It is the differences in peoples opinions that enriches life> i think.> And i guess everyone is a qualified critic in theri own right.>> These little debates on line are very interesting, it is always> good to see others opinions.> Maybe i was bias watching Taming of The Shrew, as one of the> actors in the introduction Serenaded me...> swoon..> sigh...> Sue>
NormaTue, 9 Feb 1999, 01:52 pm

Re: Shrew a night to be missed (rpt)

DEar Sue,Melville are proposing to produce "Twelfth Night' later this year, end November,here's your chance to try out for a Shakespeare role!Norma Davis (wearing MTC hat|)> So now the truth surfaces> it was not just your Renouned theatrical opinion, it was emotional....>> However, I am rather envious,> I would lurve to able to perfom in any Shakespearean play....>> one day....> Sue>
Walter PlingeTue, 9 Feb 1999, 03:26 pm

Re: Shrew a night to be missed (rpt)

This is why there are many types of plays and many ways of interpreting them,to suit individual tastes.Perth theatre does offer us a fairly braod selection to choose from.(Not that i attend as many as I would like to).Sue> Grant's experience with 'Shrew' reminds me of a recent experience> of my own at another production. In this case I walked out at half> time I hated it so but many others have raved about the show, so there.............(> I gather I missed the best half)>
Walter PlingeTue, 9 Feb 1999, 03:31 pm

Re: Shrew a night to be missed (rpt)

Thank u Norma (in MTC hat)ill keeps my eye out then....(no Acorn im not defecting - keep your hats on)variety is the spice of life hey!!!Sue> DEar Sue,> Melville are proposing to produce "Twelfth Night' later> this year, end November,> here's your chance to try out for a Shakespeare role!> Norma Davis (wearing MTC hat|)>
Grant MalcolmWed, 10 Feb 1999, 12:55 am

Re: Shrew a night to be missed (rpt)

Hi Sue> Maybe i was bias watching Taming of The Shrew, as one of the> actors in the introduction Serenaded me...> swoon..> sigh...i know my bias was showing. i performed in a production of the Shrew with Michael Loney in '86 - featured John Bell (of Bell Shakespeare fame) and Anna Volska in the leads *swoon*i've also seen three really great productions since thenthis one was the first lousy one i've seen, so it was disappointingCheersGrant
← Back to Green Room Gossip