Theatre Australia

your portal for australian theatre

An open letter to the "Walter Plunts" of this world regarding your Finley "feedback" - civility being wasted on u

Wed, 23 Jan 2008, 12:49 am
jmuzz33 posts in thread
Y'know what, having read the churlish complaints by the abovenamed in a related thread about the Finleys I took it as a comment about what the ITA does and what the ITA doesn't do (particularly with regard the Finleys) so I thought I'd shame a few of you "Walter Plunts" for the hell of it because you deserve taking down a peg or two. I thought I could shake off your comments but y'know what, SURPRISE, I couldn't. Not in a heartbeat. I dislike you simply because you're anonymous. No, truely. (this post is starting to become Pinter-like in prose - sorry 'bout that). I think you're the worst thing about amateur theatre - ego unchecked and unchallenged. We need you like we need a dose of piles (I was going to say syphillis but it's a moderated forum). You offer nothing constructive which is rude and you're rude....which is unforgiveable. Let me stoop to your level (except you know who I am) because I wanted to see what it was like. Feels good - think I'll continue. Here's the challenge - do you sit on Walter Plunt's side of the fence or not? If so, read on. I'm the outgoing ITA treasurer. I filled the role of treasurer this year and did a damn good job if I may say so as did those before me. I filled the role because THE LACK OF VOLUNTEERS FROM THE AFFILIATE CLUBS WAS ASTOUNDING. Everyone get that? Good, lets move on. Let's make sure it doesn't happen again Walter. You have a mouth obviously, wanna job? Yeah...thought not. I work over 60 hours a week in a professional capacity and like you all I enjoy being involved in amateur theatre in something other than an administration role. Sometimes my role as treasurer chews up my (whole freaking)weekend whilst I'm juggling lines (script, not the drug) and professional commitments. I have Friday off - thats my time. Up til now I haven't complained. Up til now. You people who complain about what we do and don't do - you who hide behind your "Walter Plunt" pseudonyms - how many of you are on your local theatres' committee? (kudos to Jeff Hansen in the related thread - cogent argument eloquently put - we don't have a solution to it as yet but at least it was reasonably argued and you're doing something for local theatre at a committee level, well done mate). While I'm at it (and to prove I'm unbiased) I understand that "Alias" comments were made from the heart although your intent may have been misinterpreted (negative feedback isn't necessarily WRONG feedback). You are wrong about bias though - just trust me on this :) Look at the average age of your local theatre committee - how old are they? Is the average age increasing? Why is that? Could it be the youngbloods of the "I-generation" want to be fed roles and do little else? (I'm assuming you're young and immature Walter Plunt - if not, hang your head in freaking shame). If so, continue your whinging - sooner or later there will be no-one to listen. Obviously there are people in the forums who want change. Who has the balls to promote it? Hmmmmmmmmm? Yeah, thought not. Go back to sleep Walter. How many of the Walters who complain turn up at AGMs? How many Walters THANK the adjudicators for VOLUNTEERING their time to turn up at their shows? How many Walters ask to bring their ideas to the ITA meetings? (we're a committee, not an autocracy). How many Walters think "y'know, maybe they've done this in response to feedback they've had before" (sound of crickets chirping) Yep, thought so. I like reasoned arguments. I love people who debate and promote constructive feedback. I despise cowards and people who use the word "suck" or "crap" without being at least a partways witty whenever they provide feedback on this site, e.g "I think the ITA suck-seed". (That would be at least funny in principle and I could high five it). Walter Plunt, you stand accused of having complained without offering anything more than that - you don't deserve the Finleys, Dramafest, Masterclasses or anything else for that matter. Suffer in your jocks!!! (it's a moderated forum - I'd be more explicit in person) THE ITA WILL DIE WITHOUT YOUR SUPPORT. Attend the ITA AGM and change my view that we have leeches like "Walter Plunt" in our community - please. By the way, I can vouch that I'm not an orphan - certain others in our committee work longer hours professionally or commit to other leadership roles in the theatre community other than the ITA. I write this from a very deep concern that the ITA faces a crises in regard to having fresh blood driving it in the years ahead. It makes me angry. I saw a lot of happy faces at the Finleys last Saturday catching up with old friends in a relaxed environment. I drove Beryl Silvester who has interracted in the Perth theatre community for the better part of 5 decades to the night and she caught up with many people she hadn't seen in many a long year. The Finleys isn't about awards solely people - it's about coming together, fellowship, having a drink with old mates, running into people you haven't seen in years. I ran around like a mad sod most of the night doing this and that and gave the most apalling best actor/best actress ntro ever in the history of the awards but I had fun and I'm not ashamed we didn't give out an award for "Best Lighting" or "Best Sound".......oh hang on, we did....but I guess you had to be there. Get involved people or cease your complaining. Here endeth the lesson. Thank you to the majority who provided heartfelt and thoughtful response to the initial forum - lots to be taken from your comments. However, if you missed the night, you missed Perth Theatre coming together (right now as "the beatles" said) :) "Phew" - I feel better now.

Dear Jmuzz,

Wed, 23 Jan 2008, 08:02 pm
Walter Plinge
Dear Jmuzz, I am not the original and infamous Walter Plunt, who's comment you have posted on here. A nasty and incorrect assumption you have made there. I use many variations on the walter name. There are more than one person who posts under these variations. As you opened your original post with ""Walter Plunts" of this world", I assume you are upset with anyone who posts anonymously. As I said originally, I understand your frustration at some of the nay sayers on this site. I take it from your posts you must be involved closely with the ITA and have a lot of passion for theatre and especially the development of amatuer theatre in perth. Unfortunately for you however, this is a public site. There will ALWAYS be people who don't agree with you and who will even post things that are down right nasty. You have a choice either to ignore them and move on, or you can indulge them by getting angry and giving them what they want: a reaction. People have a right to their opinion what ever they may be. One can only hope that people are careful in what they post on these sites. I do not visit this site often, though this past weeks I have been checking in on Finley Award news as it interests me. I choose to remain anonymous. Forgive me, but I am old fashioned in that I don't want to send out my details over the internet if I don't have to. That's just me. My original post suggested that not all posts from Walter, or other anonymous posters are negative, and I've selected a few for your perusal (and anyone else who would like to focus on the positives of this website.) "Yes, what was the result of announcing the nominations early? Will it become a regular thing? Can someone also list the winners?" ""By working together to promote each other's work, we build a culture of participation in the performing arts that will yield benefits for us all. Remember we all thrive on each other's considered contributions, generous praise and thoughtful criticism". We would all do well to remember the credo of this site. " (Passer-by.) "so - WILL they release nominations again?" "Although, it does give companies that are based a few hours away a better incentive to travel all that way, and encourage them to bring along loved ones who they would like to share their success with. Just a suggestion of course. Oh Norma, nothing wrong with some civil discussion...tut tut." "Can anyone tell me why the Finley Awards are called that? Are they named after anyone?" "You can please all of the people some the time, you can please some of the people all of the time, but you can't please all of the people all of the time. There are always snipers in the wings, unfortunately that is all they do, snipe. If you ask for their solution they are like politicians, no policies just snipe at the opposition. In my opinion far too many thespians are awards orientated, they forget that a full house every night is the best reward you can get. Keep up the good work Jarrod and other committee members." "I'd like to congratulate the ITA for releasing nominations. How exciting, I'm dying to know who wins now!" "KS? Kimberley Shaw? Is that you, you cheeky scamp?" As I am not involved with the ITA whatsoever, most of the people who post on this site are as good as anonymous to me, as I don't know who you are and your names don't give much away. 'Jmuzz' is as good as Walter to me. You didn't include your real name in any of your posts - which I can understand. A bit of netphobia on my behalf there too. Don't put all the Walter and other anonymous posters in the same bucket. A big thanks to Labrug for reading my original post in a calm frame of mind. Take a deep breath, and continue to do the good work you do in supporting WA theatre.

Thread (33 posts)

← Back to Green Room Gossip