Where have all the good men gone?
Wed, 13 Dec 2006, 01:31 pmStephen Gummerson41 posts in thread
Where have all the good men gone?
Wed, 13 Dec 2006, 01:31 pmdevil's advocate
My only comment is to agree
Good thing I'm not a
not taking any side
Less females? Well all I
Sorry, I was speaking on
Looking back from 55 years old.
Actually I've just realised
ABS stats
Too True
What? Walter, I'm not sure
There's often a shortage of
There's often a shortage of
How choosing the play affects choice
Actually I tend to agree
Oh Yes?
War Plays
Many War Plays, like "Breaker Morant" are predominantly male casts. BTW, Breaker is the play Kizza is referring to. Then there are numerous Aussie plays, those 'Blokey' plays which a very dominant male presence.
Then there are authors like Anthony Booth who writes plays quite frequently for all female casts. Most of these are One Act Plays, but still...
Continuing the thread Mr Ayckbourne (British Playwright) has written several productions where a female has the lead role in a equitable gender cast. "A Woman in Mind" comes to mind.
J.M.Barrie (author of "Peter Pan") Wrote several plays were females dominated e.g. "Quality Street", and then he wrote others where men dominated ("Peter Pan" being one of them.)
Some of the Stock Plays that we see each and every year "The Importance of Being Earnest", "Pride and Prejudice", "Rent", G&S, Shakespeare, and so forth have a very good spread across the genders and frequently for not have a dominate presence.
Mr Walter Plingefunkster, I think the issue is more that there are simply less men actively engaged in theatre at a community level. It has very little to with the type of plays being played. The problem comes to casting a play. More often than not, you can easily cast your female roles but have to go on a scavenger hunt for men.
From personal experience, I could have my pick of plays. I certainly have an easier time than some of the Female Performers I have worked with. That I do believe is due at least in part to the high demand for men and the low supply.
An interesting anecdotal bit of info, before King Charles (the 2nd?) decreed that women could perform on stage, theatre was nothing but men. Men playing men, men playing women and girls. Men playing dogs!!! After the decree, the number of men in theatre DROPPED!! It didn't remain constant to the rising number of women, it actually dropped. Men who had played female parts all their lives were suddenly out a job. More men preferred to watch women on stage then to actually be on stage themselves. Theatre took on a completely new and strongly sexual aspect that previously had been absent. This may have even led to the Men's only clubs we see today, although I think this was more a combination of prostitution practises at the time along with the ability to perform on-stage. There had been a strong female performance underground for many years prior to the decree.
I think the truth is that most men would prefer to watch then participate. In the days were they couldn't watch (females on stage that is) they portrayed, but why portray when the real thing is there? Theatre is generally looked down upon by "men" these days. I know my parents were never too keen about my interest in theatre. It is simply not a "man's" world anymore.
Men are voyeuristic creatures most of the time. Take the stereotype. Comes home from work, kicks of the shoes and turns on the telly to watch sport, the news, whatever. Women on the whole prefer to be actually doing things.
That apathy generates a lack of participating numbers, and take into account that a similar lack would exist in professional theatre. The ease for men to go from Community to Professional is slightly higher than that of women because there is a call for more men. Notice I say slightly higher. They do not want to white wash the market with average talent.
But I think the pendulum is beginning to swing the other way. I believe there has been a growing number of men joining the ranks of theatre participants. It is still under represented but it is growing. The number of High Profile, or Role Model Men in Theatre is growing. New generations are seeing people like Kevin Spacey, Hugh Jackman, Patrick Stewart, and many many more strutting about on-stage, apparently making good money, and obviously enjoying it also. This encouragement is the prime driving factor in the growing trend, a return of men to theatre.
I have no idea how this is going to read. It was a stream of conscious diatribe. How you can understand it.
Absit invidia
Jeff Watkins
Perth based Actor/Performer
who can also sing and dance
Fight/Sword Choreographer
Virgin Director
UPstageWA Rep
Maybe if theatres stopped
Where?
Question? What theatres are you refering to? I don't feel awash in Archaic British Comedies. At least, not over this side of the country.
Absit invidia
Jeff Watkins
Perth based Actor/Performer
who can also sing and dance
Fight/Sword Choreographer
Virgin Director
UPstageWA Rep
interesting
How to get them then?
have you tried
Right here in Perth... all
Put forward good plays please rather than critisize
Sweeping Statement
All the Theatres? I think that there would be a few that would take offense or refute that statement. Stirling Players for a start has done a number of Aussie Productions. Endeavour recently had a very NEW British production (previously not done in WA) and Garrick Theatre are proud supporters of local playwrights. Certainly they will still have the familiar shows because there is a demand for them but to say they are overdoing it is stretching the friendship a bit far.
I am certain that there is others out there and if their supporters are to read this thread, ... well you may have just opened a can-o-worms.
I have a question for you, if you feel they way you do, just where are you looking for theatrical experience? Maybe you should have a word in the ear of the theatres in question, the ones 'awash' in old-hat, Her Majesty's pleasures. You never know, they may actually listen.
Absit invidia
Jeff Watkins
Perth based Actor/Performer
who can also sing and dance
Fight/Sword Choreographer
Virgin Director
UPstageWA Rep
Down a tangent
Interesting side issues coming up there Nev, but firstly I totally agree, and am happy to see the increase in male role models who are not what one would consider beefy-Aussie-blokes, or "beefy males" doing high energy musicals (Ah la Boy From Oz.) Then see those same performers do something like X-men, well, it just goes to show that the bloke image is taking a down turn.
On another not, I ws watching a doco called "The Perfect English Village" Over the weekend and in one of the segments, they presented a Village Dramatic play. The point of interest was the cast were ALL female, even the male parts.
One of the cast members made the comment that the men (her husband in particular) were too 'shy' to make a fool of themselves on stage. They (he) were quite happy to make a fool of themselves in public or at social engagements, but it was something about doing it on stage that had them keeping away. Keeping in mind that this was back in 91 of course, I think there would still be much of a similar sentiment today.
What, does 'making a fool of yourself' on stage carry a more official status than being an idoit at the local pub? Apparently so. Mind you, as I think about it, I remember having similar feelings myself about theatre. My first theatrical experience which nearly turned me off-theatre (which would have made my parents happy ;-) LOL) was the difference between being a school kid in the play-ground to playing and singing on-stage. So maybe there is something to that also...
Absit invidia
Jeff Watkins
Perth based Actor/Performer
who can also sing and dance
Fight/Sword Choreographer
Virgin Director
UPstageWA Rep
Not being a male, I can't
The Majority
My point being that the majority still suffer from stigmatised sight. Those that have already joined the growing ranks of me in theatre are most often adventurous types, like myself. Most of the male performers I have worked with are quite prepared to pose themselves a serious challenge.
Once you get over the 'Making a fool of yourself on-stage' hurdle, then everything else seems small potatoes. That is coming from a male who can relate. I previously mentioned my bad experience. It took me years to even reconsider theatre. Even whe I did, I joined a small youth theatre group and litterally mucked about with them for a while before having the balls to actually take our stuff on-stage. However, once I had walked the boards, I don't think you will ever see me off them, apart from the occasional break here and there.
Absit invidia
Jeff Watkins
Perth based Actor/Performer
who can also sing and dance
Fight/Sword Choreographer
Virgin Director
UPstageWA Rep
Actually ...
Great Actors don't die ...
They become great Driectors, Playwrights, Producers, etc.
Absit invidia
Jeff Watkins
Perth based Actor/Performer
who can also sing and dance
Fight/Sword Choreographer
Virgin Director
UPstageWA Rep
Thankyou
"Gender bending" OK by me as long as they look & sound the part
observation
Disillusion
I have seen this also. People becoming so blind by their own naive ambition that they won't accept anything less, and when they do get less, they head for the hills. It is easy to get 'sucked' into the machinations of the Theatrical or Film Star Dream. Those with a somewhat more healthy and realistic yet determined approach usually do better than those with star-eyed visions and delusions of grandeur.
Anyone who can throw away a Dream as easily as some of these philistines you mention never really believed in the dream to begin with.
Absit invidia
Jeff Watkins
Perth based Actor/Performer
who can also sing and dance
Fight/Sword Choreographer
Virgin Director
UPstageWA Rep
men
Issue still there but cast all parts at auditions
men in perth
Craig
Underlying political issues in Sydney music theatre
Darkness
A very bleak picture that one. Every area has it Tight-nit groups and there are a few small ones in Perth. This seems (from your description) to take things to a very different level.
Here's hoping you find the crack (which is always there but often hard to find) that breaks the whole thing open.
Absit invidia
Jeff Watkins
Perth based Actor/Performer
who can also sing and dance
Fight/Sword Choreographer
Virgin Director